Monday, March 22, 2010

Book 1: Her Fearful Symmetry

Her Fearful Symmetry was both an engrossing and infuriating experience. There is nothing more disappointing to me than a book that promises to become a favorite early on and then veers hopelessly off course towards the end. Having finished the book yesterday afternoon I’ve gauged my feelings and decided that despite the bad, there was enough good to recommend this novel (with reservations).

Set in an apartment building bordering a real London burial ground, Highgate Cemetery, it is a story about relationships with people, with places, and with life and death.

Elspeth Noblin has just died as the novel opens, leaving behind her grieving lover, Robert, to deal with the consequences of an odd request left in her will. Twenty years prior, Elspeth and her twin sister, Edie had a mysterious falling out. Following Elspeth’s death, Edie’s twin daughters Valentina and Julia receive a letter stating they have been left Elspeth’s London flat. It comes with one caveat: they must live together in the apartment for one year before they may keep it or sell it. The twins’ parents are forbidden to enter Elspeth’s apartment and so sets up one of the ongoing mysteries of the plot: what caused their estrangement?

The author, Audrey Niffenegger, whose The Time Traveler’s Wife you may have recently seen at the movie theater, is a very talented writer. She slips easily in and out of the characters’ points-of-view making the novel move swiftly on. One moment Robert is fretting over introducing himself to the twins, the next, Martin, the upstairs neighbor who suffers from OCD contemplates what ritual he can perform so he might leave his bed safely, then we watch as Elspeth learns how to make her presence known to Valentina and Julia as they putter around her flat.

What? Elspeth is dead, how can she be watching the twins, you ask? Well, I must have forgotten to mention that Her Fearful Symmetry is also a ghost story. Perhaps this is unsurprising when the cemetery setting is considered. Elements of the paranormal weave their way through the narrative, seemingly innocent enough until they take a turn for the unsettling and sometimes even horrifying.

It comes down to this: I really enjoyed Niffenegger’s writing. Her characters are extremely well constructed and it is easy to feel as if you know them almost instantly. In part she paints a heartbreaking tale about what it is like to lose your lover and your best friend. But she also shows the tedious and claustrophobic side of being too close to someone, the feeling that there is never a moment alone or anything not shared.

My problem with Her Fearful Symmetry is that for the first two thirds of the novel I was entranced by the well drawn characters and moody atmosphere. Then, rather inexplicably, Robert, Elspeth, and the twins begin to do things so very unlike what the characters I thought I understood would do. You might argue that no one knows her characters better than the writer, but I felt there was nothing to justify the behaviors exhibited by the main characters in the last third of the novel.

My advice is to read this book, but keep an open mind. Don’t rely too heavily on my opinions; enjoy how beautiful the prose is and how lovely certain moments can be (such as Robert and Elspeth's remembrances of their living past together and his mourning just after her death). Then decide for yourself how well you liked this book. I’d rather read an altogether not completely satisfying book than no book at all.